By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
CGI-Quality said:
riderz13371 said:
JayWood2010 said:


Well the only two series they have is InFamous and Sly Cooper.  Their average company rating is an 83 on metacritic.  As I said, they make decent games and good games but they have yet to make a game that would be considered great.  Dont get the two mixed up.  Good is not great.  God of War = Great. Sly = Good.

Not trying to disrespect them or anything, but I feel they get a lot of praise simply because they are an exclusive company.  If Sly Cooper and InFamous went multiplatform then they would lose a lot of that praise that they get.

Why do you say they are overrated!?!? Damn everytime you say that I feel like I have to prove something to you. Well, Sucker Punch is not overrated in my opinion. You say that have only made 2 great series but you have to remember that it's a total of 5 games and they have all received 83+ rating on meta critic. I think they have already made a great game. I don't believe it's fair to compare God of War to Sly Cooper. Sly Cooper was one of the greatest platformers during the PS2 era and I just think it's unfair to compare a platformer to a hack n slash type of game. 

They don't get enough praise, the games they create are unique and deserve so much more attention. The Sly series has only sold 4 million on a console that has a 150m userbase, I just don't see this as being overrated. inFamous has also sold 4 million on a platform with 70 mill userbase. I feel Sucker Punch is forgotten as a great developer because of the likes of Naughty Dog, 343, SSM etc. Everytime I look at the improvements they made in inFamous 2 I always think of what they are capable of doing next.

I agree that Sucker Punch isn't "over-rated", but if you continue to argue with it, we'll have an entire thread ruined over a single comment (albeit, an unnecessary one, but it is just his opinion). Forget about it, keep your topic relevant.

OT: Never played the Sly games, but I felt both inFAMOUS titles were great (the first one more so). I doubt we'll see a third on PS3, but I can see them opening it on PS4 and moving to a new IP a few years after.


you have to wonder though why jaywood feels the need to insert these comments in just about any thread on a ps exclusive

i don't see him doing so for any ms games or any nintendo games

anyway ot i loved i2 but as some have said the endings pretty much completed the story