VGChartz Greatest User Tournament 2012 - Round 10

[Shinobi-san]

morenoingrato said:

Shinobi-san said:

amp316 said:
Boo! Moreno should have made it to the next round.

Weird round. Most of these members aren't very active.

5p - Archbrix
4p - Green Sky
3p- wfz
2p- Proclus
1p- Khuutra (only since he doesn't want to be involved in this)

Green sky has been really active this year. If not one of the most active users....

Moreno isnt really around anymore though so its really hard for him to compete against boutros and axum who are old users and stayed active throughout the years

Well, I'm not realy inactive as I do post regularly. I'm not discrediting the community's choice though, as Boutros and Axumblade are truly legends and deserved to pass.

I don't think people should win this simply cos they legends...for me its all about the contribution made during the year. Remember thats why this is held every year...otherwise you might as well call it Vgchartz Greatest User Tournament of all time.

So many people see a big name and just put it first....it irritates me cos a lof of the unknown active guys who contribute majorly to discussion for the year in focus usually miss out...A good example is this round. Green sky might still lose out to Khuutra...even though any active user knows khuutra isnt really around much (that doesnt mean he doesnt post at all etc.) and Green sky is really active. Thats why i respect the well known guys that sit out regularly. D21lewis is a good example....that guy would come close to winning every year and i dont think he even has to post much during the year to get there....he also sits out most years

Not saying every big name should sit out...just giving my opinion on how this usually goes down. I almost always base my rankings first on maintained activity and contribution through out the year. Everything else comes second.