| makingmusic476 said: This is definitive proof that SG is BS. Soriku, are you reading this? |
Incorrect. A public statement in an interview is hardly definitive in terms of what they have or don't have in the works after this Wii project, let alone proof that everything said by SG is false.
Now I despise the rumor mill quite a bit, so I sympathize with your position (and personally I actually tend to agree with your conclusion). But what I despise more is bad logic and there is no logical implication being made here regarding the validity of SG or his/her/its rumors excepting possibly the rumor about Factor 5's future projects, and even that implication requires further information before a definitive answer can be found..
Put simply there are two distinct possibilities remaining that are not dismissed by this statement and as a result there is no logical implication.
(A) Surfer Girl is correct and Eggebrecht is either unaware(unlikely) of the project or Factor 5 is unwilling to discuss their future projects right now
(B) Surfer Girl is wrong/mistaken and Factor 5 is being truthful.
Without something else to eliminate one of these possibilities there is no definitive proof of anything. Common sense can obviously play a role in what you believe and help you lean one way or another but that is far from a definitive position.
Of course if you want to draw your own conclusion thats a whole other deal...I'm just referring to the strictest terms of boolean logic. And in that regard 'p' does not imply 'q' this time...so to speak.
 |
| To Each Man, Responsibility |
