Can't really say for all time, but this generation GTA IV and Skyrim.
GTA IV - It's movement was clunky, the whole environment is grey and lifeless it lacked variety in vehicles, it was boring and the story crawled along at a snails pace.
Skyrim - Sure it looks pretty and has a large open world but apart from that doesn't have a lot going for it, the combat is repetitive and simplistic and there are very few memorable characters and very poor storytelling.
And no these aren't overrated because I simply disliked the game, even games I don't like such as mario I can still see the appeal but these two games aren't good by any stretch of the imagination yet still have ridiculously high metascores.
EDIT: I have to say I am very disappointed in the hate for Uncharted, I really don't see what's not to love, Great characters, fun gameplay, great graphics, puzzles and a lot of action.
EDIT: Also Batman Arkham Asylum, that game was just aweful, 2 button spam combat with such bland gameplay and story, I feel the only reason it got high reveiws is because it's got batman in it.
