The whole problem with this whole 'debate' is that there is ZERO proper context to put hell, earth and heaven in. Not to mention God, the individual soul and the purpose of it all.
In fact, in the 'Theology' of the OP, there really is no inherent explanation of the purpose of anything at all. No wonder he's a full-on atheist.
If the best theology I came up with sounded like yours then I sure as hell would be an atheist too.