Wasn't a case of scary... it was a case of WTF?! when the chainsaw crew came a knocking... :)
First and second RE was a bit of a twitcher for me. But Silent Hill 1 and 2 was the main arse twitcher as you didn't dare touch half the stuff or visit half of the places in the game.
Bit of a explaination...
Resident Evil - Character usually has skill in arms
Silent Hill - Character doesn't usually have skill with arms...
Place your bet on survival rate!
Good to see this site is still going