By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Mr Khan said:

Question for everyone in-thread: What is the game in your top 50 with the lowest metacritic score? Or, if it comes from before the days of metacritic, what game was widely regarded as mediocre or poor by others?

The lowest-ranked game on my list is Yoshi's Story.

Mine is Digimon World 4. It and Digimon World 3 were slammed in reviews.

Even though I agree with critics that Digimon World 4 was a poorly made game, I 100% disagree with World 3's metacritic. It was even quite impressive at the time, it should have gotten a MUCH better scores than it did.

I think of these two games in particular every time I need an example of why one's own opinion >>>>>> a critic's. I enjoyed playing these game SOOOOO much.

Also, even though FFXIII didn't get the low scores those two did, some would say it is disproportionately high on my list based on its meta. I loved it regardless of what anyone said.