the fallacy thread NOW HIRING! fallacy mods!

[dsgrue3]

happydolphin said:

dsgrue3 said:

I don't really care to comment upon what he was trying to prove, but you absolutely used strawman in an attempt to invalidate his claim which failed logically anyway.

1. All animals, exclusive of humans, have demonstrated cases of homosexuality.

2. Humans are animals.

I cannot conclude from these two statements that Humans display homosexuality. 

No I did not, I agree with you and I was only trying to prove that his logic failed. Despite your agree with me, you assume that I used a strawman when I didn't, I simply pointed out the flaw in his logic, whereas you simply indicated that it is flawed.

I guess you're just extremely bad at explaining what was a simple logical fallacy. His premise was fine, his conclusion wasn't.