BEST OVERALL EDITION? (Uncharted)

[platformmaster918]

TruckOSaurus said:

platformmaster918 said:

Mensrea said:
Uncharted 2 absolutely blew me away. I loved it to death. It's one of the best games I have ever played. Uncharted 3 was a huge disappointment. The story, set pieces, and shooting were all mediocre.

funny because I thought 3 was better in specifically all those areas.  The shooting seemed basically the same to me.  The set peices I definitely preffered in 3 though.

The sinking ship is the only set piece I prefer in UC3 over UC2. I'd say:

Sinking ship > Train

Istanbul = Syria

Snow and mountains of Tibet > Yemen desert

Borneo >  France forest

Shambhala >>>>> Ubar

from the plane crash to the spider chases to the bar fight to the sinking city to the boat that made me wonder "which way is up" about the same time Drake said it (seriously that happened) I just preferred the moments in U3 better.