The highest scoring game or the most praised game, which deserves the GOTY?

[Andrespetmonkey]

sales2099 said:

Andrespetmonkey said:

sales2099 said:

Ya, Walking Dead deserves the GOTY, both in reviews and gameplay.

Gameplay? Out of all games suggested for GOTY TWD has the most restricted, basic gameplay. It's the writing and the acting that make it amazing.

So VGAs are over and that won?

Eh? I'm not saying it shouldn't of won. I voted for it! I'm saying the gameplay has nothing to do with why it won (it's mostly very shallow), so I just thought it was odd that you'd mention that.