I didn't realize that Dragon's Lair was acclaimed enough to count as overrated...
Anyhow, from that list I would pick Gears of War; not a bad game, just overrated, IMO. I haven't played Skylanders, though.
Other games/series that I personally find overrated this gen are Assassin's Creed, Mass Effect, The Elder Scrolls games and Fallout 3/New Vegas. Just not worthy of the hype to me personally, but I don't particularly dislike them (except for Fallout; really didn't care for that at all).







