They can probably be divided in categories:
Best game overall: RE4 Wii Edition
Best platformer/ best game as a kid: Super Mario 64
Best adventure: Zelda OoT (played it on GC), with Twilight Princess as a runner-up
Best multiplayer game: Super Smash Bros. Melee (hope Brawl is even better)
Best atmosphere: REmake
Best shooter: Timesplitters Future Perfect, followed by RE:UC
Best RPG: Tales of Symphonia
I drink your milkshake.