Is Wonderbook the PS3's killer app?

[Scisca]

I never understood why this game got so much hate after E3. To me it seems like a solid idea that will appeal to parents. And it doesn't really matter that it may be too complicated for them, since it's their kids who are going to play it, right? And since Sony managed to put a really hot brand on it (Harry Potter may not be red hot now, but it still is massive), it should really do well. I've seen Wonderbooks a week ago in 3 stores next to my house and there were just piles of them. When I went there 2 days ago, there was only about 25% of that left! And the hottest period for buying gifts is still ahead of us. I'm sure it will do good in Europe, where PS3 is the dominating console, so many young dads already own it and may look at it as a good way of getting Move without getting their wives angry (since they bought it for the kid...).
Obviously this is the kind of game that will sell during "gift periods", so we can expect a massive Disney onslaught next X-mas. It will nosedive in January, but will come back each X-mas.