We must reach an agreement on the meaning of "flop"

[Jay520]

miz1q2w3e said:

Jay520 said:

But a game cannot be a flop while simultaneously not being a flop. This will not due. One of the methods must supercede the other.

Of course it can't. I'm saying the condition for a flop be an OR statement.

How do we know which to apply and when?