37. Red Dead Redemption (PS3)
Or Grand Theft Horse as it's sometimes jokingly called. I keep changing my opinion of this game, as can be seen if you look over its placing on my lists over the last couple of years. The first year it was rather high up, and then last year it didn't make it all, but I replayed it earlier this year and decided it needed to be in. You play as a former outlaw forcibly recruited by the government to track down and kill his old gang members in the old west and Mexico. It plays similarly to GTA, with the addition of being able to go out and hunt wildlife, or be hunted by the wildlife in return (listen out for those damn cougars that can come out of nowhere).
Number 36 is one of about half a dozen versions of a popular fighter.