By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

I think you already made your decision, but... (Edit: oops, just read the last page of posts ha. Yeah, you definitely already made your decision. Darn it this entire post is pretty much pointless;( Still would be interested to hear your thoughts once finishing the game though)

A couple months back I made a thread asking which series was better between Sly and J&D. One of the things I remember ppl consistently saying (same thing some are saying in your thread) was that J&D 1 was great, but 2/3 went downhill.

I ended up buying J&D 1 real cheap to give it a try. I'm guessing I played almost 1/3 of the game by the time I decided it wasn't fun enough to continue. I also watched some gameplay videos of J&D 2, and it didn't look very appealing or fun. Because of these things, I decided not to buy 2/3 and instead bought the Sly collection. While the gameplay in Sly got repetitive and sometimes boring, I liked it bc I liked the characters (Sly, Bentley, and Carmelita that is; NOT Murray, who is unbearably annoying in Sly 2/3). I didn't really enjoy Jak though, and Daxter was a little too over the top, although his character design is awesome.

I'd be interested to hear what you think. I may have to give the rest of J&D 1 a play-through someday.