Probably Nintendo gamers, Pro Smashers are legit at other fighting games and if we can snake rainbow road in Mario Kart you better believe with can drift abuse in Mod nation. I am kidding.
It is a really tough question. The fighting game community mostly centers are the PS3, but then again fightsticks make it so they can really play on any system. Nintendo has their share of competitive games with Mario Kart, Smash, Pokemon, and Strikers. Old school Nintendo had tecmo bowl. Not to mention it was featured in the Wiz. PS3 and Xbox share a lot of multiplat shooters and fighters which are generally preferred to be played on PS3. Xbox has a handful of its own exclusive shooters and for some reason sport games are preferred on Xbox 360. It would be hard to tell. Unfortunately most pro gamers stick with a single genre so I don't think there really is a true best gamer. Nor would a competition like the TC suggest be feasible.
95% of gamers don't know they are noobs, the 5% who do won't be noobs for long
Check out my kickstarter project: http://kck.st/15CEuUT
Check out my blog: http://www.metropolisgaming.com
