By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
thetonestarr said:
Actually, no. Let's try not making ignorant statements next time, eh? I've stated at least five or six dozen times on these boards that I am in no way a fanboy. I have stated dozens of times that I plan on purchasing a 360 as soon as I can afford it, and I have made it very clear that if I ever go for a blu-ray player, it will most definitely be a PS3 (and with the possible price-cuts that are coming around, the PS3 may be a more viable solution soon enough).

Don't call me a fanboy. You just make yourself look like a tool.

There are quite a few problems with releasing it for the PS3 or 360. First off, those versions are the least guaranteed successes. The PS3 and 360 both have much more niche markets than the Wii, and they have sold far less worldwide. When releasing a game for a very unique market, you never release it for the console that will most likely have trouble reaching that market. That's why high-end graphics shooters don't come out for the Wii - it has WAY too much trouble reaching the markets that those specific games market towards. The Wii is, in every way, reaching for the type of people that would purchase this game. It's only common sense to expect it to do best on the Wii.

Second, let's talk about the market a game like this is aiming toward. This game requires you to have a real, working electric guitar at home. I'll wager to guess that the majority of gamers, particularly those that own a PS3/360, do not own an electric guitar, nor do they plan on purchasing one anytime soon, even for a game like this. Of course, I'm not saying that no gamers own an electric guitar, but I can almost guarantee that the vast majority of them don't. So, if you're going to market a game like this to gamers, you're going to want to go to the (1) biggest number of gamers, (2) biggest potential number of gamers, (3) console that is most likely to be able to have people that can afford picking up something like this. The Wii is the cheapest console, and putting games out for it is the cheapest. So, an aspiring developer will consider that.

Three, Gametank is a brand-new developer. This is the first game they'll have released. As a result, they don't exactly have the funds nor resources to just whore their games out. They have to go for the most sure shots. Given the above statements, it's obvious that the Wii provides the most sure shot of all consoles. In fact, they may not even be able to afford developing a Wii version. In order to release a Wii version, they would pretty much have to get a large publisher's help with it (which wouldn't be so hard, though - I'm sure dozens of publishers would jump on the chance to get a successful competitor to Guitar Hero and Rockband out there). In order to release any new versions for any console, they have to do a pretty big amount of work to port it. That can be costly. Without the funds of prior gamesales available, they have to greatly limit the amount of costs they rack up. That means they can't develop a version for every single console available. They just don't have those funds. Naturally, that means they have to select the console that will be the most surefire success. That is obviously the Wii, in a case such as this.

I find it rather funny that you say that the PS3/X360 have more niche markets yet:

Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock
Activision1446,0501,873,773

 
Guitar Hero III: Legends of Rock
Activision1460,5131,424,868

 
Rock Band
EA1137,138818,272

Guitar Hero II
Activision4413,0411,574,333

 

 Kind of odd that you argue better sales on the Wii, and not the X360, yet the X360 version of GH3 has sold better by 400,000 units, and Guitar Hero 2, and Rock Band. Kind of strange, eh?

Maybe a Xbox 360 version would be best, no? I fail to see how the X360 version would be a bad idea.

On your second argument: you have absolutely no demographics to say that the X360/PS3 owners don't play guitar. Making that sort of statement with no fact(s) behind it is rather wrong.

What kind of market does the Wii garner toward? Very young or older gamers, for both genders (or atleast thats most people's arguments "since it's casual"). But the fact is that playing guitar is male-dominated (90%) and actual guitarist demographics are vastly more favored to those with more disposable income, and might just be the exact opposite of your point.

 I certainly agree that since the company is a new developer that it might present some difficulties to the X360/PS3, but lets look at the game: it closely resembles a PC-type game, that might first be released for the PC. Guess which sytem is the easiest to port from PC to? The Xbox 360. Not the Wii, not the PS3. So which one would give the developer the better environment to work on? The easier platform with the larger demographic (both in terms of previous-type game sales, and the guitar-playing demographic), or the worse one(s)?



Back from the dead, I'm afraid.