By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

The system IS broken, but this crummy review is not the problem. The problem is gross score inflation, not one low-ball review. And the problem is also the weird belief from fans that anything below a 80/100 is a mediocre score. We as fans are part of this problem. I've seen posts in this thread saying Halo 4 can't possibly be lower than a 80. Well, yes it can. It could be worse. It could be a bad game. We need to drop our own unreasonable expectations, and maybe critics will start to grade games more realistically. Ideally, it would be the other way around -- critics would inform their readers -- but I don't have much faith in that scenario.