Yes, let's add iron sights to Quake 3 Arena. Let's just imagine ourselves in the middle of a super rocket jump just pressing that precious right click and aiming down the sights of a freaking rail gun. Cuz nothing says accuracy like limiting your field of view and filling half of your screen with two parallel bars between which you just want to sandwich your target.
In the end, this whole debate will be decided by sales and user feedback. If both are well and good, then the masses have spoken on what it is they prefer. Not a perfect barometer of the situation, true, but it'll show pretty well how much people actually want the game to change.
Some arguments here made me thing along the lines of "We'll shove our 'evolution' down your throat and show you the PROPER way of experiencing entertainment!" Frightening thought.
