It's hard to say, to be honest. The PS2 had some absolute classics. Even with series that have continued on, many of them peaked with the PS2 era.
I mean, Silent Hill 2, Shadow of the Colossus, SSX 3 & Tricky, Suikoden III & V, the first Disgaea, Final Fantasy X, and the Gran Turismo PS2 games were fantastic. Not that this gen hasn't been awesome with entries from the west, but the style has changed so much, with some of my favorite types of games having all but disappeared. Even some of the better Japanese games, like Valkyria Chronicles, which I loved, haven't been as big as they should have been, or as big as they would have been on the PS2.
On the other hand, the FPS genre, which I've grown to like a lot, has improved tremendously, with some of my favorite games of all time being Fallout 3/NV and Borderlands 1 & 2, and Portal 2.
I think I'm gonna call it a tie.
