Soleron on 07 October 2012
Games should be reviewed on jobs they are doing for the customer.
Example: Wii Fit did something that the customer didn't have before, Wii Music did not. Although both would score low in the traditional categories of graphics, sound, presentation and so on, and 'gamers' would hate both, they clearly deserve different scores.
Pokemon B/W 2 is clearly an expansion, people will buy it as an expansion (and skip it if they don't care), and it should be judged on that basis. If the next mainline Pokemon game doesn't have lots of new content it deserves these scores, but not now. It's doing the job the customer expects.
