Top 10 games of the Generation rules

[Troll_Whisperer]

JayWood2010 said:

Troll_Whisperer said:
If the site is biased towards Sony then you'll get a list biased towards Sony, but there's nothing you can do. That will be the true general VGC result and will show VGC's taste, you should stick with that.

Plus, I'm pretty sure there are at least as many Nintendo fans.

I understand that but I remember the last time we did this Killzone 2 was in the top 10.  Killzone isnt even the best FPS let alone one of the best games this gen.  I don't mind it being a little bias but I dont want it to be a landslide like it has been in recent years

I did something similar a few months ago and Skyrim won. Halo was at the top too. The problem was not enough people voted.

I don't know, you can give it a try, maybe it won't be as bad as you think.

 

Edit: here's what I got, I asked people to vote for their top 3 and gave 3pt to the top option, 2pt to the second and 1pt to the third.

Skyrim -12pt
Halo 3 -11pt
Uncharted 3 -8pt
Mass Effect  2 -8pt
Super Mario Galaxy -8
Demons Souls -8

 

Pretty balanced list. I got about 50 votes only though, so perhaps the top 3 idea wasn't good because too many games had the same number of points (as you can see with the four-way tie). Top 10 is better considering the number of votes you can get on this site, but I didn't want to repeat the thread.