My quick thoughts:
HD - irrelevant to most Nintendo franchises. Would be nice for Metroid. Otherwise I have a 360.
You are assuming that Nintendo wont create worlds that take advantage of the HD capabilities of the WiiU. Plus Zelda HD come on.
Gamepad - The lack of true motion gaming is a definite minus in my books. I have yet to see it really adding anything new.
I guess you missed that screen on the controller then.
Online - I will believe it when I actually see it. Would be appreciated.
Fair point
Support - Nintendo fans have said this every generation since GC and been disappointed every time. I don't expect WiiU to be different. For the record, I said it to for Wii (but it was outselling the other two consoles combined at the time).
The WiiU already has support from third parties and they will likely continue while it is cheap to port games and if the WiiU can continue to generate signifigant sales.
Games - Yes, I'm sure like GC and Wii before it, WiiU will have some great games. When enough of them come out, I will consider getting a WiiU. Unless the competition has offered something better.
This is the Game of Thrones
Where you either win
or you DIE
