This isn't a PS3 owner question, this is a gamer question haha. I don't see how the outcome could change by which onwer you ask, as the outcome will only differ person to person.
Personally I choose E, and yes I do have a PS3 in my house. It takes a combo of all 4 to make a game good. And let me specify, when I see good graphics, I mean graphics that are polished and that fit the atmosphere/idea the game is trying to create. Meaning just because a game has super realistic graphics doesn't mean I will classify it as good.