Game Purchase help! $25 credit from Newegg and not sure what to buy.

[superchunk]

So, I have a $25 GC to Newegg and I've narrowed it to three choices. (all free shipping)

1) RE5 Gold Edition for $20

2) Mortal Kombat for $18

3) Red Dead Redemption GOTY Edition for $28.

With options 1 or 2 I get a game my kids can play (no foul language) and still have a few bucks to buy something else. Option 3 is a game I'm not positive I'll even like in the long run but have only hard great things.

What say you? (Please don't just answer poll but also give feedback)

 

EDIT: My kids would vote MK as they love the demo. However, they also loved RE4 on Wii.