Top 10 games on Metacritic this gen, do you agree?

[Aldro]

TheBardsSong said:

Kresnik said:

Mr.Ashtear said:
Also, Twilight Princess has a 95 too (96 for the GC version). Little Big Planet has nothing to do there, give that spot to Zelda pls.

Zelda has 95 off 73 reviews, while LBP has 95 from 85 reviews.  I presume that's how they've chosen it.

That doesn't make sense. The requirement for an average on the site is 4, not 74.

EDIT: Oh, just realized the 96 was for Gamecube.

Well Uncharted 2 has 96 out of 105 reviews,

Bioshock has 96 out of 88 reviews

 

Yet Bioshock is higher than UC2 so I don't think thats how it works.