Top 10 games on Metacritic this gen, do you agree?

[Immortal]

Sam3o said:

Immortal said:
Considering that the only game on there that I own - Super Mario Galaxy - was the most disappointing Nintendo game I've ever played and that I don't want to own any of the others, something tells me my opinion is nothing like that of video game critics.
Well, these scores hardly reflect anything very tangible or objective so I suppose that's to be expected, :P.

Really, that much!? I'm the opposite when it comes to Mario Galaxy. Sure, the game could've been more difficult, and the hub world bigger and more interesting, but what they're only minor complaints tome. What did you fing about the game that was so dissapointing?

Oh, you've misjudged me. I'm one of those casuals who bought their first home console this generation with the Wii (well, I owned a DS, GBA and GBC before, but still). In general, I don't find games too easy; I find them too hard, :P.

It wasn't that with SMG, though. I don't know why, but I found it just plain annoying to go through. I've since realized that I'm basically that way with almost all 3D games so it's really not the game's fault so much as it is my inherent dislike for the ability to go up, down, right, left, forward and backward at the same time. Also, I bought the game imagining it to be "the best game ever" from reviews and such, not realizing that it really wasn't for me, so I was even more disappointed, really.

I really just prefer games like Pokemon and 2D Mario over Nintendo's more "core", critically acclaimed titles for the most part (well, I liked Brawl, but that's as far as it goes).