GameOver22 on 21 August 2012
No, I don't agree. The only titles on that list I think deserve to be there are Bioshock and LittleBigPlanet (I would put LBP2 instead of 1 on the list though). However, I haven't played The Orange Box or Skyrim yet. I'm willing to concede that The Orange Box might deserve to be there, but Skyrim (if it is similar to Oblivion) has no business on the list.
Personally, there are about 5-6 games (that I've played) that I think truly stand out this generation. After that, there are just a huge number of good but not quite great games.
