By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Here you guys go.  GOTY list determined by the largest amalgam of respected video game journalism in the industry.

Title
Plat
Company
Reviews
Avg.
Vote
Avg
Score
1. Super Mario Galaxy WII Nintendo 62 8.9 97.235%
2. The Orange Box PC EA Games 30 9.6 96.183%
3. The Orange Box X360 EA Games 48 9.1 96.079%
4. BioShock X360 2K Games 85 9.2 95.235%
5. BioShock PC 2K Games 42 8.3 94.964%
6. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare X360 Activision 67 8.9 94.149%
7. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare PS3 Activision 41 7.8 93.432%
8. Halo 3 X360 Microsoft Game Studios 82 8.5 93.357%
9. The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion PS3 Bethesda Softworks 51 7.7 93.216%
10. Rock Band X360 MTV Games 47 8.2 93.137%
11. Galactic Civilizations II: Dark Avatar PC Stardock 24 7.9 92.917%
12. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare PC Activision 36 8.2 92.889%
13. God of War II PS2 SCEA 77 9.0 92.454%
14. Guitar Hero II X360 RedOctane 56 8.1 91.959%
15. World of Warcraft: The Burning Crusade PC Blizzard Entertainment 45 7.5 91.056%
16. Resident Evil 4: Wii Edition WII Capcom 56 8.8 90.995%
17. Final Fantasy VI Advance GBA Nintendo 23 8.6 90.891%
18. Rock Band PS3 MTV Games 23 -- 90.835%
19. Crysis PC EA Games 52 7.8 90.715%
20. Mass Effect X360 Microsoft Game Studios 69 9.1 90.713%

There, now can we stop posting every single random "who cares" GOTY list in the universe?  Thanks, the year ended a month ago.  MOVE ON!