I'm not surprised to see people on this board unhappy with that list.
I think Rock Band does deserve to be that high. It is a well put together game that really advanced it's genre and provides a multiplayer experience that is unparalleled for that type of game.
I think that you could probably rearrange the top 5 in any order and someone is going to think they are full of shit. Personally, I think Mass Effect is a Top 5 game, but really the list is full of good games that deserve to be in the top 10.
The judges are pretty diverse. Yes, MTV News is on the list but it is a long list and I believe MTV news does report on games. The list does include the editors from every major game website and most magazines.
Thank god for the disable signatures option.
