By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Christhor said:

For one, if you put a screenshot of SMB3 next to SMW, or SMG next to SMS, you would easily be able to tell the difference between the games.

I figured I'd jump to this one, because it stands out as a good demonstration of your mistake.

NSMB Wii

NSMB U

Similar? Yes. Same? No. Pay close attention to the aesthetics of it. They look similar in the same way that Sunshine and Galaxy look similar. They're designed to look similar, specifically to keep them within the same "set". But each entry is different.

But even if they looked the same in screenshots, the fact is that they'd look different in videos. And while you claim that the various powerups are "bells and whistles", they're not. Levels are designed around the set of powerups. The Ice Flower, for instance, allows you to do things you wouldn't be able to do without it, and that results in some interesting features in a number of the "above water" levels, for instance. There's also things you just can't reach without standing on iced enemies.

Beyond that, you admit that NSMB Wii brought something new and innovative to the series. Well, that's the most recent one to be released, and there's still a lot we don't know about NSMB 2. We only found out about the DLC within the last week. We have no idea how boss battles will be working, we have no idea what the storyline is going to be like, we have no idea what the significance of the million coins is, and we have no idea if the touchscreen will have any use beyond that of NSMB1.

In short, it's absurd to argue that there isn't innovation in any but one of the games in the series, when only two have been released and we only have partial information on the third and a few bits and pieces of the fourth - especially given that what little we know about NSMB2 suggests that there's more to find out. As for appearances, there is a lot more difference when you place them side-by-side than if you compare them in your memory.

EDIT: Oh, and regarding the whole "walking in a straight line" thing... if interesting gameplay had been made by having the player walk in a straight line, and then they added more in the sequel by allowing the player to walk in various directions, then yes, that would be an innovation. Indeed, I could imagine a rhythm game working in precisely this way - you walk forwards or stop moving depending on the beats. And then, a sequel could allow the player to walk along a more complicated path that caused the music to change as you move along it, resulting in a different pattern depending on the path taken. That would definitely be an innovation.

Innovation isn't about the change itself, it's about that change's impact on gameplay. If replacing the tanooki tail with the super cape means that levels work differently, and the levels are designed with that change in mind, then it's an innovation. Innovation literally means "introducing something new". If you're introducing a new mechanic into a game, and it changes the game, it's innovation.