Aielyn said:
DLC is new *to 2D Mario*. That makes it an innovation for 2D Mario. It may be common elsewhere, but it wasn't present in 2D Mario before this game. Or would you suggest that adding active multiplayer to NSMB Wii isn't an innovation because other games in other franchises have had multiplayer before? Also note that each 2D Mario introduces new powerups, which change up the gameplay, and thus the level design. Using the propeller-hat powerup in NSMB Wii is very different from using the Raccoon Tail in NSMB2, which is different from using the Flying Squirrel suit in NSMB U. And the other point to make is that NSMB isn't a yearly franchise, or something. It has, so far, been one-per-console, and they're in high demand, as demonstrated by sales numbers. Each 2D Mario introduces new features and new twists that change the level design and the way that the game plays. Coin Rush mode introduces an in-game speedrun challenge with a twist - and as a result of that mode, levels have been designed in a way that suits such play. NSMB Wii was designed to take advantage of four player multiplayer. It's no different from the introduction of Yoshi in Super Mario World - it changes level design. It's no different, in this respect, from having massively different gravity in Super Mario Galaxy, for instance. |
If I had made a game that was just walking in a straight line, then released a sequel where you could move in all directions, would that be innovation? Would it be innovation if I added jumping? If we were to follow your logic, then that should be considered innovation. It would also mean that the best way to be able to innovate is by making a franchise way behind the times.
As noted, the powerups do change the gameplay, but not that much. It's bells and whistles, you still feel like you are playing the same game with minor changes.
NSMB might not be a yearly franchies at the moment, but it is not that far away from it. The one on the Wii was released in 2009, which was not that long ago and now they currently have two in development at the same time. They will probably released one a year after the other.
Are you saying that SMW was just as much a rehash of SMB3 and SMG of SMS, as NSMB2/U are of their predecessors? That is an outragous claim. For one, if you put a screenshot of SMB3 next to SMW, or SMG next to SMS, you would easily be able to tell the difference between the games. They also had widely different feels to them, whereas NSWB has largely the same feel. With some difference with the powerups, but nothing major.
Again, I am not condemning you for liking these games. That is alright. But they are similar enough, and common enough, to be called rehashes.







