Best/Worst Presidents

[Mr Khan]

richardhutnik said:

SamuelRSmith said:
Good GOD this thread got massive.

Along with this and "If I wanted America to fail..." (or whatever it was called), I think I've found the winning formula for threads. A catchy thread title that would intrigue people, followed by a highly controversial first post.

If your idea is to generate long threads with lost of posts, then yes you are onto something.  If your idea is to get beyond long threads with lots of posts which consists of choirs screaming at one another, as you preach to your own, and have things go nowhere, then you might want look for ways to reformulate.

I think this thread did better than "If I wanted America to fail" it invites people to give and defend their opinions, and although we temporarily got derailed by WWII discussion, we have at least remained civil and provided rational discussion on methods of governance and historical pieces.