By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Kasz216 on 31 May 2012
Edit Thread
rocketpig said:
Mr Khan said:
rocketpig said:
bouzane said:
2. This may be true but it doesn't change the fact that the Axis was crushed almost entirely by the Soviets with comparatively little being accomplished by the British.

I find it a little difficult to swallow that the Soviets singled-handedly crushed the entirety of the Axis powers when they fought neither Italy nor Japan in force. Italy was almost a laughing stock, for sure... Japan, not so much.

Threat of the Soviet Union (despite their nonagression pact) did hurt the Japanese war effort, as they had significant resources invested in Manchuria awaiting the invasion, which could have been used to build control over the Aleutians or make the difference on Guadalcanal.

They distracted the Japanese, yes. But distraction without major conflict is not the same thing as actually defeating the enemy.

You'd be surprised.

Some historians now suggest the reason Japan surrendered is because they thought Russia was going to invade.

It generally gets lost in common conversiation but in reality it was found that when Japan was trying to send the US a surrender message through Russia before the second nuclear bomb dropped... the reality was. 

Japan wasn't trying to surrender.  They were trying to put off a Russian invasion by convincing the Russians the war was over so they would stop there preperations. 

The Japanese gameplan was to force the US to invade... while keeping russia unprepaired... deal heavy casualties and force the US to break it's treaty with the British, French and Russians to seek nothing but unconditional surrender.  Allowing Japan to keep the emepror and it's government, and possibly some of it's outside conquest.

 

This is something generally ignored because people either want to use that fake surrender as a claim that the second nuclear bomb was worthless or that the second nuclear bomb is what forced the surrender.   (It really did help, but that combined with the russian invasion were what did it.)