By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
IIIIITHE1IIIII on 14 May 2012
Edit Thread
Wh1pL4shL1ve_007 said:
IIIIITHE1IIIII said:

Bolded: No, that would be me, since you obviously don't see the major logical flaw in the underlined where He created humans that are destined to go to hell.

Free will and an almighty God can only co-exist if God is able to create a rock that is so heavy that He cannot lift it. Can God do such a thing?

Something tells me that you haven read the convrsation between me and NintendoPie.

Here.

Lifting covers up the definition of translation, which means moving something from one point in space to another. With this in mind, the real question would be, "Can God move a rock from one location in space to another that is larger than possible?" In order for the rock to not be able to move from one space to another, it would have to be larger than space itself. However, it is impossible for a rock to be larger than space, as space will always adjust itself to cover the space of the rock. If the supposed rock was out of space-time dimension, then the question would not make sense, because it would be impossible to move an object from one location in space to another if there is no space to begin with, meaning the faulting is with the logic of the question and not God's capabilities.

If your talking about infinite weight force and irrelevant surface area. Then thats another matter. God can simply take away gravity in order to move this object in this three dimentional world. 


Underlined: That's exactly what I am doing. Weight has nothing to do with size, it's about a magnetic force (which in this case is unlimitedly strong). God is not lifting the rock if He removes this force.