B+C) Actually, i never conceded that. For extreme cases some guy who's never been to a doctor could walk out in front of a subway train and be instantly killed on the scene. Or jump off a bridge and commit suicide. There is only one inevitability in life... and that is it's end.
What I DID argue was that even if something WAS legal because it was inevitable ONLY the inevitable could be covered. Otherwise you'd be saying that Government for example could mandate us to buy 12 tons of broccoli a month because... everybodys got to eat! Though nobody is going to eat that much.
Furthermore, I'd note that you are using healthcare as a catch all, for dozens of things. Like Food. Or like how buying or selling anything (Practically inevitable) is all broadly commerce.
Additionally, when you pay for health insurance. Each unit of health insurance covers you for THAT month. Therefore if you don't benefit from services that month. There is no inevitability.
Also, I don't advocate an "Eat what you kill" system. I think everyone SHOULD have health insurance.(Though everyone should decide they want it not forced into it or less preferably but more acceptable, a proper government run healthcare system that would actually be legal. Paid out of the general budget, with no special taxes towards it.)
I'm arguing the law here.
As for the Car insurance thing... you missed the point. Car insurance is legal because driving isn't a right... if Driving WAS a right it would be illegal to force people to pay for car insurance.
If Healthcare is a right. It would be illegal to force people to pay for health insurance. Because it's a right.
You can't charge people for rights, because rights are inherent. If you are fined for something, and you claim freedom of speech, your fine is revoked and waived.
Therefore if someone didn't get insurance you couldn't fine them.
