Smithy RPG on 16 March 2012
It's not my favorite game (but I really like it), but Luigi's Mansion is #1 with about 16 playthroughs. I had 12 next to the star literally only 1 yr after it came out. Short game ftw!
Second is my favorite game ever (Paper Mario), with about 12. I ran out of save slots, so I had to delete some as I played. And this was before I rebought the game.
After that, it is hard. OoT was around 6, Bully (idk but I LOVE that game) around 5, Sunshine around 4-6, PM2 around 4-5. Ratchet and Clank games around 4 each. I've played virtually every single game I owned at least 3 times.
