By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

I never complained about the balance prof. It was a punishing setup for town though, and I'll get to that later. Nor was it swingy IMO. Baal had the most "swing control" followed by TOS. The passive kill ability was very minimal swing.

Town deserved to lose this one, though most didn't play horribly.
Spurge lied about who he was, which would have been grand if planned due to his actual role, but then he slipped up bad. Stefl never had a chance to try and save Spurge, stop placing blame on him.
moreno made no sense, and though I had an inkling he could be the princess and thus cautioned the votes to cease towards him.(also in a successful effort to draw out scum, radish, imo) The problem is siblings already flipped and a second town-punishing role like a princess isn't going to be on people's minds. Then moreno lynches himself.. o.O
nen and FF both claimed cop. With watcher-siblings and a flavor cop already flipped, both existing isn't a likely thought in a game of 14. Even without the other powers known, you can essentially count on the two roles butting heads at some point and a mislynch occuring. Unless the naive cop dies first, and then the other should still be under some strong suspicion. If the normal cop dies first the naive cop will realize he's basically useless(were you trolling with the 75% correct scans remark? lol)
Truck should have been lynched over radish. I can understand others not trusting FF fully, but he shouldn't have been thinking two cops with broken results exist. TOS probably would have been the lynch of the day too if radish didn't basically throw himself in front of the bus, and that move alone unknowingly kept town from turning it around.

I gotta run at the moment, but food for thought:
Town could lynch not-town at EVERY opportunity and still lose. Chew on that.