By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

It's very hard to pick. Every one of them (all three) had their awesome pieces. The N64 started of with a new formula that is still enjoyable. To this day, I even play it against others online because it has less lag than Brawl! Then Melee came and improved in every possible aspect: Gameplay, maps, way more characters, Tournaments! Everything went better! And then there was Brawl that kept improving everything... except gameplay/character movement. It also could have had WAY more online options available but Nintendo completely screwed up that part. Luckily, I hardly ever used online and only played it with my friends so that wasn't really an issue for me.

All in all:

N64: 8/10 (although, a big plus for being first)
GC: 9,5
Wii:8,5