I've wrote 20 Uncharted 3 reviews and I'm just gonna say 10/10 straight up.
Pros:
Amazing visuals
Refined gameplay
Best Melee system in a game I've ever scene
Amazing quick time events
Solid intro
Great Story
Best MP I've ever played
Great co-op mode that can last you for hours
Amazing amount of customization (online)
Improved over UC2 on almost every point
Great Pacing
Good and fast updates
Cons:
Weak Split-screen design. (I usually play by my self so that doesn't really affect me)
Overall:
This game is the best game I've played and deserves a 10.