Reasonable on 18 January 2012
I'm all over the place on this one. Great game world, some fun missions, some good mechanics... but the usual weaknesses, immersion breaking bugs and wobbly control of NPCs - from totally silly comments at the wrong time to amusing repeat comments - seem at times to be trying their best to destroy all sense of a living place.
So I'm going for 8.5 currently. Should be over 9 really but after extended play the cracks really start to make their presence felt.
When it all hangs together though it's superb - but the problem is too often it doesn't hang together. Less filler quests please, more polish.
Try to be reasonable... its easier than you think...
