MAFIA - Round 36.5 - Short Practice Game

[Wonktonodi]

Linkzmax said:

Wonktonodi said:

Linkzmax said:

If you can't cite a time when radish was actually useful as town then you're making it up to sound better, period. You must remember when you were lynched for trying to have radish lynched just for being useless, right?

If I know something is not true and say it is I am making something up. If I vaguely recall something here and there over the course of all the games I am playing, without being able to site it exactly I am being honest. I still say he has been useful as town over the coarse of the games I played with him in, the moment you are referring to was day 1 of my 3rd game so I had only had 2 games with him and I felt a bit harsh for saying it then.  Now since you seem so sure I am making up that radish has been useful as town, you are pretty much saying he has always been useless as town and from a guy who is often giving him advice and trying to help him out that is really harsh.

Now as for you

You say I got MVP twice as scum to make me sound worse. Now was that you lying to make me sound worse or you remembering wrong and thus mistaking the facts to make a point?  Now that was a much easier thing to look up. Heck it's even easier to remember it was your round and last round.

Now let me know when you are done calling me a liar.

It is harsh, but I wouldn't call it very innaccurate. And yes it means I fail as a coach too. Saying he's more useful as town implies that he generally is more useful, it should be just as easy to recall a time where that's true.

I misremembered as I don't really care for awards. I mean they're cool, but I'd much rather just be playing another game. YOU brought up being a high priority target for being MVP twice recently, I questioned how that makes you awesome town and the implication was more how does it make you awesome in this game. Still, I conceded the point to you "Sorry I thought you were mafia and MVP twice in a row, but maybe it was FF that was mafia twice in a row? My archives is severly lacking. Point granted in that case." 

As for looking things up, your entire case on radish was based on your one statement. The MVP thing was extremely minor.

My case for radish? That is one other thing I dislike I was never driving the lynch of radish, I wanted a MDJ lynched. I was just pointing out how your case making him town wasn't a town tell because he has just done the same thing as scum. you then ask a minor question I gave a vague answer to and you are making that out to be my entire case LOL

However I will continue to disagree that he is less helpful to the town as town. and if you should look bakc trying to find that he is never helpful look for things like this

did he hammer more scum as town then as scum?

is he more posative and cheerful as a townie or as scum?

His participation as town vs scum?

when he is town and thinks there needs to be a lynch does he at least have a candidate?

Hey even in my game he did better when he was town then when he was scum and he was both that game(or is the general outlook of a game not good enough)

So thanks for the advice however I already follow it.  I do suggest you drop this though, I really don't like you calling me a liar.