Well, I'm going to go out on a limb, and vote for Spurge.
Vote: Spurge
He puts a vote on Stefl yesterday, but then assures us that wasn't his target last night as the supposed vigilante. So who the hell did he target? Somebody completely random? Something about that seems a little fishy.
There just happens to have only been one kill yesterday. Whether it was from the lynch or a night kill, we don't know, but that would indicate whoever Spurge did target was either protected or something else such as a player being bussed occurred. I don't like coming out with crazy theories involving a busser, because the simple truth is that they are not very common (on Vgchartz anyways).
I would have thought that a doctor would have seen a vigilante as an important role, and hence protected that player. That would mean that Spurge was protected, not whomever Spurge targeted.
We are left with Spurge being blocked. While I have slight thoughts that a town oriented roleblocker could see reason in blocking a vigilante on night 1, I have my doubts. This would leave a mafia roleblocker in this particular instance. No offense to Spurge, but I think it would be in the mafia's best interest to let him be on night 1 as a vigilante. There is so little info from night 1 in this game that the shot would be more or less completely random, giving the mafia good odds that a townie will be taken out.
What I am getting to is this. I think if Spurge is indeed a vigilante, then he targeted Stefl last night. Why he wouldn't admit to this, I have no clue. Not just this, but I REALLY don't think Spurge as a town oriented vigilante is necessarily a good thing for the town. Vigilante is a very powerful role, and for somebody who has only played one game, it is quite the weight to be carrying on your back.
In other words, if he is indeed a vigilante, I'm not so certain it isn't in our best interest to vote him out, to eliminate the risk that his night kills will present, not to mention I still have a feeling he may be mafia. Others may completely disagree, I just have a really hard time not getting worried when you have a vigilante who may very well be picking a target out of a hat every single night.
Money can't buy happiness. Just video games, which make me happy.
