Gamespot GOTY - Editor's Choice winners are in

[Mirson]

pezus said:

Mirson said:

GS gave Uncharted 2 a 9.5 and Uncharted a 9.0; they don't seem like haters to me.

I finished U3 last night, and I wasn't impressed by it. It's too scripted for my taste.

The thing is, there's only one guy that reviews each game for them so judging from the site's scoring isn't a good way to determine if all of the other editors like Uncharted or not.

Maybe the other editors thought other games were more deserving than U3. They even stated that it wasn't easy eliminating Uncharted 3 from the nomination list. And I would agree with them.