Sony Gets Other OS Class-Action Lawsuite Dismissed

[o_O.Q]

fordy said:

o_O.Q said:

it would seem to me that "logically sound" for you means anything you happen to agree with but whatever... anyway

""For the fix to really stand it has to invalidate all previous keys and that would make all previous content unplayable," she says"

i don't really get your point... "For the fix to really stand" this part implies that at the time of the interview she herself believed the fix was effective... otherwise she wouldn't have said that

...and beyond that i haven't heard of people having issues playing back previous content and i also haven't heard of the exploit via the keys working on updated models ( since the fix )

...so either she was wrong on that part or as you seem to believe sony payed off everyone on the internet that hates them to stay quiet ( obviously if this is the case their internet patrol squads missed you )

so we return back to square 1, up till now you really haven't supported your argument with anything other than how you feel the situation should be... 

 

The problem is your definition of "fix". If it's a temporary solution to cover a deeper problem, I don't call that a fix. I call that a sticky tape solution. In that regard, she agrees with me.

So if you haven't heard of it, that must mean it's absolutely factual. I'd say give it some time, if they haven't already found something and kept it hidden, after they saw what happened to Geohotz.

Once again, they missed her. I haven't even bothered to look for others, since many others haven't bothered to give their 2 cents on the matter. But given my current knowledge on digital encryption methods and software engineering, I'm pretty confident in my own logic.

Up until now you have disregarded any shred of evidence or logic that I have put forward. You think sony is some kind of god, who never asked for this in the first place, and can never do anything wrong. Oh and on top of that, they can rewrite decades of digital encryption methods in their first attempt, since jusdging by April, they're SO good at digital security...Take off the rose tinted glasses and perhaps use some common sense on the matter...

"The problem is your definition of "fix". If it's a temporary solution to cover a deeper problem, I don't call that a fix."

well the thing with words is that they do tend to vary in meaning from context to context, when we focus on the context of technology and computing we generally accept that most devices and systems can be hacked into given enough time...

and from that then i guess i figured that when i spoke of a "fix" that it would be obvious that i was reffering to something that could be eventually be broken through, if you didn't undertand that before then i'm sorry

"I'm pretty confident in my own logic"

i know you are but it doesn't change the fact that beyond that theres not much backing up your argument

"So if you haven't heard of it, that must mean it's absolutely factual"

no its just taking the information presented to me, just like i i did when i heard that the keys had been leaked...

"You think sony is some kind of god, who never asked for this in the first place, and can never do anything wrong"

i actually don't and i was never even close to implying that i believe that they had mastered technology to such a degree that they could "rewrite decades of digital encryption methods in their first attempt" ( if i'm wrong quote me where i did )

beyond that i could as easily say that you seem to view sony as some demonic force that deserved some kind of retribution and maybe they did i wouldn't know they've never done anything to me personally maybe they have to you if so well all i can say is that i'm sorry