Uncharted 2 or Uncharted 3?

[Jay520]

d21lewis said:

ethomaz said:

d21lewis said:
And many of us would still think that U2 was more of a game and U3 was more scripted.

Really? U3 has more control scenes than U2... U2 is more scripted.

It could have more cinematic movies but the game give to you more control than U2... in U3 you have more control of Drake than U2.

Not talking about the controls--U3 adds quite a bit to the older game--I mean the parts where you actually get to play.  U3 has (or seems to have) more moments where you want to run but can't, more moments where you want to shoot but aren't allowed to, more moments where you can't mess up climbing, and more moments when the game is saying "Hey, look at this!  Isn't it awesome?" Instead of letting us do what we want.

Again, I don't want to make a laundry list (I've already done that before).  U3 is a great game.  I just think U2 is a better game.

I'm curious (I am genuinly interested in your opinion) about your list of reasons. This isn't a Forza vs Gran Turismo thread, no one's going to attack you, well, I won't at least. We haven't seen a lot of really good thread around here lately, but this seems like a thread with potential to spark a good, deep, discussion. Not like graphics threads or Forza vs GT or anything like that.

I hope to read a lot of interesting opinions in this thread, maybe I'll discover some things that I may have missed. I think if you give a list of reasons, that would prompt ethomaz or someone to discuss what you said reasonably & spark a good discussion & inform those who haven't played either. Or maybe it'll turn into a flame war with UC2 fanboys vs UC3 fanboys, I dunno. I guess when someone finds flaws in a game I find near-perfect, I become confused as to why, espescially if they are a fan of Uncharted-type games (which you obviously are). Which leaves me wondering about why they feel the way they do. I dunno, it's kinda like when you were interested in Brendude's reasons for not loving Gears of War (yes, I stalk your wall).