| Aldro said: I think everyone including us UC3 fans would hate on UC2 if the games were reversed: Judging by the poll, 35% liked UC3 more and 39% liked UC2 more. Considering UC2 is one of the highest rated exclusive this generation and the game that won the most GOTY awards this generation, Id say ND did a fucking well job :D. |
I dunno. Maybe we hold U3 to a higher standard or something but, personally, I usually have no problem saying that the newer game is the better game. I preferred MGS2 to MGS1 and MGS3 to MGS2. It's just that MGS4 did so much wrong that I hold MGS3 as the pinacle of the series. Yeah, MGS4 had deeper gameplay, better online, and such but it was possibly too ambitious and made mistakes that MGS3 didn't.
I think Zelda games got better and better since OoT but I'm not really feeling Skyward Sword, yet (only played a few hours, though). Gears 3 is better than Gears 2 which is better than Gears 1. Devil May Cry 2 sucked but Devil May Cry 3 is awesome--and Devil May Cry 4 is weak. God of War got better with every new entry. Fable 2 is better than Fable 3. Saints Row 2 is waaaaay better than SR1 but SR3 (while a very good game) is missing probably half the activities in SR2.
I don't think it comes down to which one we experienced first. I think many of us honestly feel that Uncharted 3 didn't live up to Uncharted 2. I won't make a laundry list of things U3 could have done better. I do think that, if we weren't looking at graphics, most of us would feel that the single player campaign of Uncharted 3 wasn't quite as well written and performed as the SP in U2. And many of us would still think that U2 was more of a game and U3 was more scripted.
My opinion, of course.
