Uncharted 2 or Uncharted 3?

[Aldro]

Boutros said:

Jay520 said:
Also, don't listen to any posters with under 1,000 posts. They are likely alts just trying to boast they're favorite game.

Also, don't listen to Truck. He's just sad that Nathan showed less ass than in UC2.

Also, don't listen to Boutros...ever. He said FFXIII was a good game.

That leaves the reasonable & objective Uncharted fans: Aldro, ethomaz, coolbeans, & Jay520. There's a unanimous agreement that Uncharted 3 is superior.

I have metacritic to back me up on every point. FFXIII = 83 (Good game). U2 = 96 ­ ­­> U3 = 92.

Also, it IS true that Nathan's butt in U2 > in U3. Major letdown.

UC2 = 96 > every single PS3 and Xbox 360 game aside from GTA 4

Wow what an accomplishement, and they managed to put out another 92 metacritic after having a game THAT good? DAYUM! :D

 

@OP
Uncharted is the highest acclaimed new franchise of this generation. You should play it and you will love it. Nitpicking is possible with any game, and feeling let down depends on people and what they expect HOWEVER I believe most that vote for UC2 will still say UC3 is a great game. Its just that they (and I quote a sentence from The 40 year old virgin) "Put the pussy on a pedastole". In this reference, the pussy is Uncharted 2 XD.

 

I have completed UC2 4 times (over the course of 2 years) and UC3 12 times (over the course of less than a month). I tried to play UC2 again the other night but I only made it to borneo until I was terribly bored. Like I said it depends on people. UC2 is an amazing game in my opinion, but it doesnt appeal to me at all like UC3 does. I was hyped beyond anyone when it came to UC3 and while that has failed me before, it amazingly enough delivered beyond expectations for me.