Is it OK to feel Halo 1 is the best shooter this gen???

[Reasonable]

selnor said:

Reasonable said:
On console - sure it's probably still one of if not the best for SP campaign - obviously it's MP has been eclipsed by others doing the same thing better.

However if I bring in PC I still say Half Life franchise tops it, particularly for SP campaign.

But on console sure it remains great - in fact it reminds me how much Halo itself has fallen with regards campaign, from the pitch perfect original to the weak Reach SP campaign.

I dont think Reach was weak. At least compared to the tosh  of campaigns we have nowadys. Next to Halo CE  though it has fallen.

EDIT: Halos miltiplayer IMO is the last decent Console MP. Its not unbalance with weaon upgrades and perks. Its traditional MP the way it should be.

You think MP in Halo was better than Halo 2 and 3?  Your OP was Halo 1 specifically and all my comments were about Halo 1 not the franchise.  I'd say Halo 3, Gears, CoD4 and arguably quite a few others offer more sophisticated and polished MP than Halo 1.  Halo 1 had a great SP and a great fun but rather embryonic (next to MP at the time on PC) experience that was quickly eclipsed by Halo 2 and obviously others on 360/PS3.

IMHO obviously :)